Xylitol and Heart Attacks? What You Should Know

Is Xylitol Really a Heart Risk? Let’s Look Closer.

If you’ve seen headlines lately warning that xylitol causes heart attacks or strokes, you’re not alone—and if you felt a little panicked, I don’t blame you. But let’s take a deep breath, look beyond the clickbait, and unpack what the research actually says.

Sometimes I think (okay… a lot of times I think) the media intentionally misrepresents scientific studies to stir up fear or controversy. And unfortunately, I’m seeing this kind of confusion spill into professional circles—even among dentists on social media.

Let’s be clear:
You do NOT need to throw out your xylitol toothpaste.

Here’s why:

1. Xylitol Is Natural—Your Body Makes It!

The study in question (PMID: 38842092, for my fellow research lovers) identified an association between elevated blood xylitol levels and an increased risk of cardiovascular events. What most headlines didn’t tell you is that the primary focus was on endogenous xylitol—the kind your body naturally produces as part of glucose metabolism. This is not the same as the tiny, localized amounts used in oral care products like toothpaste and chewing gum.

2. Correlation Is Not Causation

Just because people with higher xylitol levels had more cardiovascular events doesn’t mean xylitol caused those events. In fact, higher endogenous xylitol might simply be a marker of metabolic dysfunction or oxidative stress—factors that are already known to increase cardiovascular risk. It’s like blaming the fire truck for the fire just because it’s always at the scene.

3. What About Xylitol in Toothpaste?

Toothpaste contains very small, topical doses of xylitol. It’s not ingested in significant quantities, and the amount absorbed into the bloodstream is negligible—certainly nowhere near the levels seen in the study participants. Unless you're literally swallowing tubes of toothpaste or bathing in xylitol mouthwash, you’re probably just fine.

The exception? If you’re sensitive to sugar alcohols or have a pup who likes to sneak into your bathroom drawer, that’s a different story. Xylitol is extremely toxic to dogs, so pet owners, please be extra cautious.

4. Xylitol Is a Powerful Tool Against Tooth Decay

Xylitol is not some fringe sweetener—it’s one of the most well-researched natural ingredients in dentistry. It inhibits the growth of cavity-causing bacteria like Streptococcus mutans, helps neutralize acids in the mouth, and promotes remineralization. It’s especially helpful for those struggling with dry mouth or frequent cavities.

So... is this the beginning of the end for xylitol in oral care? Or just another wave of fear-mongering designed to keep us dependent on fluoride and Big Pharma-endorsed solutions?

Honestly, I’m leaning toward the latter.

Let’s stay informed, yes—but keep in mind… Not every headline tells the whole story.

Bottom Line: Don’t panic. Xylitol remains a safe and effective ingredient in oral health care. And if you love your natural toothpaste, you have zero reason to part ways with it because of this small, easily misunderstood study.

‍